WHAT THE EVIDENCE SAYS
A synthesis of 172 papers found that 89 studies evaluated biodiversity relative to counterfactual land uses, producing 112 comparisons because some studies used several controls. Around 68.8% of comparisons favored sacred forests; results were less favorable against formal protected areas and over repeated monitoring than in single snapshots.
WHY IT MATTERS / OUR READ
The useful distinction is not between 'protected' and 'unprotected' on a map. Community-protected cultural landscapes can protect real biodiversity, but sustained outcomes depend on continuing local authority, restrictions and support. Any prospective OECM designation should be site-specific and respect custodians' priorities.
CAVEATS / UNCERTAINTY
Comparators varied; studies concentrated in India and parts of Asia/Africa. Past biodiversity advantage does not prove future persistence, nor confer community consent for any external designation.
SOURCE
Biodiversity and Conservation — Chandler & Cook (2026)
View original evidence ↗
