Forest stakeholders did not choose the modeled drought-resilience leaders
WHAT THE EVIDENCE SAYS
Researchers linked CAFE ecohydrological decision support to three rounds of participatory workshops in four living labs spanning pine forest, argan woodland and cork-oak silvopasture. Participants focused on wildfire, water and biomass and selected plausible interventions, but did not select the model's highest resilience options at any site; choices were statistically indistinguishable from random in that metric.
WHY IT MATTERS / OUR READ
A stewardship plan should show decision-makers the resilience trade-off alongside locally valued outputs. In drought- and fire-prone landscapes, document which alternative optimizes which outcome, then decide explicitly rather than equating agreement with long-term resilience. This is a decision-design lesson, not a case for overriding community priorities.
CAVEATS / UNCERTAINTY
Resilience rankings depend on the CAFE model and its assumptions; choosing other outcomes is not necessarily an error. Four geographically specific living labs cannot justify a universal prescription.
SOURCE
Pérez-Romero et al., Frontiers in Forests and Global Change (9 Nov 2026)
View original evidence ↗
Four Mediterranean living labs show why explicit resilience metrics belong alongside participatory management priorities.
Read the Wild Lands assessment →