Skip to content
Ecological Intelligence

Ecological evidence.
Independent perspective.
Explore Wild Lands ↗

Ecological Intelligence / Subject

blue carbon

Peer-reviewed Latin America & Caribbean

Belize mangrove priorities look different when the community draws the map

Evidence
Peer-reviewed
Geography
Placencia Lagoon, Belize
System
Mangroves / coastal livelihoods / participatory planning

WHAT THE EVIDENCE SAYS

Five community workshops combined high-resolution habitat baselines and InVEST modeling. The participants prioritized 83 hectares of degraded mangroves for restoration and 174 hectares of healthy stands for protection, with a larger 752-hectare lagoon protection scenario. Researchers modeled possible blue-carbon, spiny lobster, tourism and sociocultural benefits.

WHY IT MATTERS / OUR READ

The useful bridge is between local ecological knowledge, a real map at implementation scale and assumptions financiers can inspect. Community priorities cannot be replaced by national extent maps; plausible benefits still require implementation and monitoring.

CAVEATS / UNCERTAINTY

Modeling assumes restored stands deliver healthy-mangrove benefits after ten years. The estimated carbon, catch and revenue are conditional scenarios, not realized gains or proven investment returns.

SOURCE

Landscape Ecology — Delevaux et al. (2026)
View original evidence ↗

Placencia residents identified 83 hectares for restoration and 174 for protection; prospective benefits are modeled, not achieved.

Read the Wild Lands assessment →
Peer-reviewed Asia

Most measured carbon in one Indonesian seagrass study lay beneath the plants

Evidence
Peer-reviewed
Geography
Derawan Islands, East Kalimantan, Indonesia
System
Seagrass meadows; coastal blue carbon; marine protected areas

WHAT THE EVIDENCE SAYS

At six monitoring stations, measured seagrass carbon-stock estimates ranged roughly 154–244 tonnes C per hectare, with approximately 99% attributed to sediment. Comparison with an earlier 2014 dataset suggested a lower mean stock by 2025; authors translated the difference into a scenario-derived carbon-dioxide-equivalent estimate.

WHY IT MATTERS / OUR READ

Blue-carbon accounting is largely a soil and sediment problem. Repeated cores and comparable methods, not simply maps of green seagrass cover, are necessary to judge long-term storage and whether a management intervention changed it.

CAVEATS / UNCERTAINTY

The roughly 36% historical difference is not an experimentally estimated cause of loss; surveys differed in context and methods. The reported annual emissions figure is calculated from stock change, not a directly measured atmosphere–ocean flux.

SOURCE

Discover Environment · Derawan seagrass carbon field comparison
View original evidence ↗

Derawan surveys highlight sediment storage and an apparent stock decline, while estimated emissions depend on assumptions.

Read the Wild Lands assessment →
Peer-reviewed

Invasive-plant control can turn a salt marsh from carbon sink to carbon source—at least during recovery

Evidence
Peer-reviewed
Geography
Eastern China
System
Coastal salt marsh

WHAT THE EVIDENCE SAYS

Researchers compared unmanaged Spartina alterniflora marsh with chemical control and cutting plus continuous flooding. Unmanaged marshes showed net carbon uptake of 13.49 Mg C ha−1 yr−1, while both control strategies shifted the system to net carbon release of 1.78–4.94 Mg C ha−1 yr−1. Chemical control increased methane emissions relative to unmanaged marshes; both treatments reduced total and surface soil carbon, and carbon-stability metrics fell sharply.

WHY IT MATTERS / OUR READ

Control can be ecologically justified for native-habitat and biodiversity goals while still carrying a carbon cost. The useful management question is therefore not whether Spartina should be controlled in the abstract, but which method, recovery trajectory and carbon tradeoff fit the site’s objectives. Carbon quantity and carbon stability also need to be kept separate.

CAVEATS / UNCERTAINTY

This is one eastern-China salt-marsh system and the study captures post-control conditions rather than the full long-term recovery trajectory. Carbon consequences do not negate biodiversity or habitat reasons for controlling the invader, and results should not be treated as universal across tidal settings or control methods.

SOURCE

Carbon Balance and Management — primary study
View original evidence ↗

An eastern China study found both herbicide and cutting-plus-flooding control of invasive Spartina reversed net carbon uptake, while the two methods changed methane, soil carbon and carbon stability in different ways.

Read the Wild Lands assessment →
Peer-reviewed Global

A better decomposition model could make some macroalgal blue-carbon estimates less comfortable

Evidence
Peer-reviewed
Geography
Multiple empirical seaweed and kelp datasets
System
Macroalgal detritus and blue-carbon processes

WHAT THE EVIDENCE SAYS

A new three-parameter decomposition model replaces a constant exponential decay rate with a time-varying formulation that allows detrital photosynthesis early in the trajectory. Implemented in a Bayesian framework and tested against seven empirical macroalgal datasets, it routinely fit decomposition dynamics better than the conventional model.

WHY IT MATTERS / OUR READ

The weak signal is accounting-related: if decomposition is modeled poorly, estimates of how long exported macroalgal carbon persists can inherit systematic error. Method improvements may therefore change confidence in seaweed carbon-removal claims before any new field sequestration estimate arrives.

CAVEATS / UNCERTAINTY

This is a modeling and statistical paper, not direct evidence that macroalgal carbon sequestration has been overestimated by a specific percentage. Better fit to decomposition data does not by itself resolve transport, burial, remineralization or long-term sequestration fate.

SOURCE

Ecological Modelling · Original evidence
View original evidence ↗

A new Bayesian model allows recently detached seaweed to keep photosynthesizing before decay dominates, outperforming conventional exponential decay across seven empirical datasets.

Read the Wild Lands assessment →
Peer-reviewed

Mangrove carbon did not increase in one simple line with stand age

Evidence
Peer-reviewed
Geography
Coastal islands, Bangladesh
System
Afforested mangrove plantations

WHAT THE EVIDENCE SAYS

Across five stand ages from 12 to 44 years on six coastal islands, Sonneratia apetala plantations showed highest vegetation and total ecosystem carbon density in the oldest stands, while soil organic carbon followed a unimodal pattern and peaked in 26-year-old stands. Older stands also shifted more belowground carbon into deeper soil layers.

WHY IT MATTERS / OUR READ

Blue-carbon trajectories depend on which carbon pool and soil depth are measured. A single age–carbon curve can therefore hide redistribution among vegetation and soil pools, which matters for monitoring protocols and claims about restoration performance.

CAVEATS / UNCERTAINTY

This is a chronosequence rather than repeated long-term measurement of the same stands, and it focuses on one planted mangrove species. Carbon storage alone does not establish biodiversity recovery or broader restoration success.

SOURCE

Environmental Research · Original evidence
View original evidence ↗

Across six Bangladeshi islands, vegetation and whole-ecosystem carbon kept building while soil organic carbon peaked at an intermediate plantation age.

Read the Wild Lands assessment →

Keep exploring

Follow the systems. Find the connections.

WildlifeLandWaterOceansClimateCitiesOne HealthGovernanceMethods / Monitoring
Browse the archive →